[Anaesthesia]

Why did Knox, in her confession to police (this is documented) state that she was in the house, heard Meredith scream, and identify the assailant as Patrick Lumumba...her ex-boss, and a man who has since proven to be innocent?

She then retracted this after Lumumba's alibi proved rock solid, and said she wasn't there at all.

[MTVN]

Originally Posted by Nedusa

Oh for God's sake.... She has been acquitted twice

It is all over.... Please move on this story is a story no more.

Time to move on.

Been found guilty twice as well

[GypsyGoth]

I don't think Amanda had a firm grip on reality back then but I still don't think she was capable of murder.

[Nedusa]

Originally Posted by MTVN

Been found guilty twice as well

I am truly amazed at some of the posts on this thread , people actually think this young women and her boyfriend suddenly turned into perverted devil worshipping sexually depraved murderers...

Based on juicy gossip and salacious tittle tattle....

[Anaesthesia]

Originally Posted by Nedusa

people actually think this young women and her boyfriend suddenly turned into perverted devil worshipping sexually depraved murderers...

Who has said they were perverted devil worshippers?

[Tom4784]

At this point her guilt or innocence doesn't matter anymore, the constant flip flopping by the italian courts has made any judgement they pass on the matter a joke.

[Brother Leon]

Originally Posted by MTVN

Guilty as hell, sad day for Meredith's family

.


Whole thing has been a mess though. Feel for her family.

[Amy Jade]

BBC are saying NOT guilty :/

[lostalex]

Originally Posted by jennyjuniper

There is enough doubt for me to not be able to say for sure if Amanda Knox is guilty or not. But the thing that left me feeling very uneasy was the fact that hours after the murder Amanda and her boyfriend were seen laughing and joking.
Not enough to label someone as guilty I know, but still.....?

but still what? you've never laughed or had the giggles at an inappropriate time? you've never found levity in a stressful situation? you want her to fall on the floor and self flagellate herself? get a grip.

[lostalex]

Originally Posted by Anaesthesia

Why did Knox, in her confession to police (this is documented) state that she was in the house, heard Meredith scream, and identify the assailant as Patrick Lumumba...her ex-boss, and a man who has since proven to be innocent?

She then retracted this after Lumumba's alibi proved rock solid, and said she wasn't there at all.

because she was beaten and tortured for HOURS before they forced her to say those things. i'm sorry, i mean they "interrogated" her for 8 hours straight before she said those things.

The italian police make guantanamo bay look like club med.

[lostalex]

Originally Posted by Anaesthesia

Who has said they were perverted devil worshippers?

The italian prosecutors said that. they claimed amanda was a witch and practicing a satanic sex ritual. lol seriously.

[lostalex]

Originally Posted by MTVN

Been found guilty twice as well

based on evidence that was completely discredited.

[lostalex]

Originally Posted by Livia

I'm confident Knox is guilty. The evidence at the apartment alone would be enough for me to believe beyond reasonable doubt that she's as guilty as sin.

what evidence at the apartment? there was ZERO DNA evidence in merediths room. the only DNA evidence in Merediths room and on her body was from rudy guide, the man that actually killed her.

please explain how amanda and rafaelle cleaned off just their DNA and left his DNA? it's physically impossible

[user104658]

I'm unsure really. It's been a total mess so anything could be true. However, Italy is rife with corruption on all levels and I do think it's perfectly plausible that the Italian police simply decided to pursue Knox and her boyfriend because they were available to arrest, and an easy way to close the case. It wouldn't surprise me at all.

[Crimson Dynamo]

you cant even send a fecking parcel to italy without it getting lost so i dont put too much faith in the legal system

[user104658]

Without it getting "lost" LT. In some postal worker's bedroom wardrobe.

[Livia]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

you cant even send a fecking parcel to italy without it getting lost so i dont put too much faith in the legal system

Only time I've ever lost luggage on a flight - Alitalia. I'm sensing a pattern here...

[Sticks]

Originally Posted by lostalex

because she was beaten and tortured for HOURS before they forced her to say those things. i'm sorry, i mean they "interrogated" her for 8 hours straight before she said those things.

The italian police make guantanamo bay look like club med.

That is a bold faced lie from the lying members of the Knox family

They did not beat or mistreat her at all!

In fact, Amanda and her parents have been convicted of slander for saying it did, when it did not

[kirklancaster]

Originally Posted by Sticks

That is a bold faced lie from the lying members of the Knox family

They did not beat or mistreat her at all!

In fact, Amanda and her parents have been convicted of slander for saying it did, when it did not

Yes - you are correct Sticks. Knox is on record stating that she was "treated well" by the Italian authorities and denying that she was ever tortured.

[Nedusa]

I don't understand why so many on here are so convinced this woman is guilty when given the farce that passed for a trial coupled with all the subsequent aquittals it would be the default position to give her the benefit of the doubt.

Coupled with this woman's good character and general upstanding normal behaviour , why would people assume she is so evil?

Glad this nightmare for her is over and slightly embarrassed by the amount of unjustified and unwarranted Amanda hate on this forum.

[Livia]

I've watched the TV shows and read the trial transcripts and I really do believe that she is guilty. I don't feel sorry for her or for her family. The people I feel sorry for are the family of the murdered girl who've lost a daughter, and who also think Knox is guilty.

[Marsh.]

Another murderer gets off. Psychotic bitch.

[Z]

I feel sorry for the Kercher family, having their daughter's reputation brought into ill repute (implying she died in a sex game gone wrong for no apparent reason - how horrible?!)

[empire]

foxy knoxy is a psychopath, she has ice cold shark eyes, and has narcissistic personality,

[lostalex]

Originally Posted by Z

I feel sorry for the Kercher family, having their daughter's reputation brought into ill repute (implying she died in a sex game gone wrong for no apparent reason - how horrible?!)

how can you feel sorry for the Kerchers? they have been disgraceful the whole time. Meredith must be ashamed of her family if her soul is watching from somewhere. The Kerchers have taken a case where one young woman was victim and instead of acting with dignity, they have victimized another young girl.

Shame on the Kerchers.