[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by Smithy

See, the system works

There'd be no more complaints too about bias modding, because everything is there in black and white about why you'll be infracted and how harsh it'll be

Yes but theres still the issue of stuff like, lets take the swear filter...

X says 'this is ****' breaking the filter

Y says 'you stupid motherfcking c unt, fcking dickheading wankface cumstain'

Both should get one points? Personally I don't think thats fair either

[Jessica.]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Yes but theres still the issue of stuff like, lets take the swear filter...

X says 'this is ****' breaking the filter

Y says 'you stupid motherfcking c unt, fcking dickheading wankface cumstain'

Both should get one points? Personally I don't think thats fair either

One is just breaking the swear filter, the other counts as breaking the swear filter AND insulting someone, so they should get the points for both things?

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Yes but theres still the issue of stuff like, lets take the swear filter...

X says 'this is ****' breaking the filter

Y says 'you stupid motherfcking c unt, fcking dickheading wankface cumstain'

Both should get one points? Personally I don't think thats fair either

Yes but the difference there is that X has simply broken the swear filter, Y would be breaking the swear filter AND attacking another member so the points build up.

I should be a mod tbh. Everyone would be getting a dozen charges for one post.

[Jessica.]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

Yes but the difference there is that X has simply broken the swear filter, Y would be breaking the swear filter AND attacking another member so the points build up.

I should be a mod tbh. Everyone would be getting a dozen charges for one post.

I literally posted that five years before you.

[Jay.]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Tbh I think the infraction system is a bit messy, and I hope this thread stays open so that we can discuss it like adults rather than someone close it because they don't like that members are wanting to have something change

I think the fact that there's no clear infraction system makes the whole thing a bit redundant, someone could get 1 point for baiting and someone else 2 points (because they were given by different mods) and the second person knocked into a ban because of it, I think we should be able to see the amount of points given and there should be a full list of infractionable offences and the # of points given when they're commited

It's really annoying when mods say "if xxx carries on I'm giving out straight bans" in no way is that ever fair and I've never seen it done on any other forums, I wouldn't have a problem with TiBB staff if there was a system like I mentioned before, because then you know even if a mod dislikes you, you're only getting the set amount of points rather than them upping it (even slightly) because they dislike you

I know what I'm trying to say but it's not coming out properly

Originally Posted by Jessica.

A great method would be:

"Did you really mean it when you told Marsh he has squinty eyes?"
"No, I was joking, he knows that"
"Well I got a report, it seems to have offended someone"
"Oh sorry, I'll delete it, I won't tell him he has squinty eyes any more"

Verus

I am here for both of these, I think they could both work pretty well tbh.

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by arista

thats your view


Dramatic.


TIBB Staff
do a top job


If I buy this Forum
all staff are going to get a One Off Cash
Payment (Tax Free) gift

Can you just contribute to the matter at band rather than having a go at everything and anything members post, it's SO irritating trying to have a proper discussion with you quoting every other post just making snipey comments

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Yes but theres still the issue of stuff like, lets take the swear filter...

X says 'this is ****' breaking the filter

Y says 'you stupid motherfcking c unt, fcking dickheading wankface cumstain'

Both should get one points? Personally I don't think thats fair either

Well the first person would get points for breaking the filter and the second for breaking the filter and insulting someone, is that not how it'd work?

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Well the first person would get points for breaking the filter and the second for breaking the filter and insulting someone, is that not how it'd work?

My point was more, some rulebreaks while technically the same thing, are worse than others :S Some insults are worse, especially personal ones. etc

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

My point was more, some rulebreaks while technically the same thing, are worse than others :S Some insults are worse, especially personal ones. etc

I get the point you're making but I think that in cases like that, other infractionable offences are made so extra points are added, so one could be "insult" and another would be "offensive language" both worth one point whereas the other person would just get one point for the insult

If you get it, I didn't explain it very well

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by Smithy

I get the point you're making but I think that in cases like that, other infractionable offences are made so extra points are added, so one could be "insult" and another would be "offensive language" both worth one point whereas the other person would just get one point for the insult

If you get it, I didn't explain it very well

Yeah I get it

I do think a change to the system is long overdue tbh

But no matter what we do, lets be honest, there will still be a select few (usually those who are banned most often) who feel its all so unfair

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Yeah I get it

I do think a change to the system is long overdue tbh

But no matter what we do, lets be honest, there will still be a select few (usually those who are banned most often) who feel its all so unfair

Yeah, people will complain regardless of the situation, but I think with some of the stuff that's been mentioned, it'll be a lot clearer, a lot fairer and a lot harder to contest