[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by WOMBAI

She never had any intention of leaving - just a ploy for more attention - as the show has transformed her otherwise failing career. Without Girls Aloud - which isn't exactly great - she is nothing!

I wouldn't say her career was failing before, GA are doing very well and she didn't have a solo career until this year. I think she's a decent judge, very hit and miss though.

I'm hoping Dannii's back though she's the best judge out the lot.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by Dezzy

I wouldn't say her career was failing before, GA are doing very well and she didn't have a solo career until this year. I think she's a decent judge, very hit and miss though.

I'm hoping Dannii's back though she's the best judge out the lot.

X Factor came along at the perfect time, their career was starting to go down the pan. Can't Speak French just scraped into the top 10, then when X Factor was out of the way they only made it to number 10 on one song, and for the first time failed to get the top 10 with another. Then they conveniently "went on a break" whilst Cheryl is pretending to be Beyonce.