Quote:
Originally Posted by Jack_
Well it's got to be, or else everyone would agree she was either in tune or out of tune, surely?
Just like you can't tell whether a Cher fan is just saying they were in tune because they like her, they can't tell whether you're just saying she wasn't in tune because you dislike her. How do you decipher who is right and who is wrong? It's not possible, because both sides will disagree with each other - thus it's got to be an opinion, no?
|
Stating if someone is in tune or not is an observation; bias playing into it is another issue entirely - but I think the vast majority of users who post in the X Factor forum can be sensible enough to pass judgment on whether a performance was in tune or not without being biased.
Threaded Mode