[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Jack_

I said she was off-key for one small part. It seems to me most people in this thread [bar Vicky, who has just stated differently] are stating that she was out of tune for the entire song. That's something I don't agree with.

I never said the whole song either. And eventhough I don't like her I wouldn't say it unless I thought. I readily admitted that she was very good last week

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

I never said the whole song either. And eventhough I don't like her I wouldn't say it unless I thought. I readily admitted that she was very good last week

Fair enough then. So I guess we can all agree that she was out of tune in parts, but for the majority she was in tune?

I'll settle for that, because that's what I believe