[Stevep]

Originally Posted by the truth

why do you ignore all other points? if it was your show, called the voice, about the voice, would you pay someone with zero music knowledge or experience at all, with zero personality, no discernible talent, poor social and listening skills, £420,000 to read a few corny lines off dummy cards and talk over everyone else in a monotone voice?

She isn't there to add her expertise in the field of music, she is not a critic ,she is there to present and nothing more. If you have a problem with her presenting style, which you obviously do, then fine have a go, but her musical knowledge shouldn't really come into it. Out of interest do you have a problem with Reggie? He seems to add nothing in terms of critique even though he has a music backround.

And tbf, what sort of music knowledge are you after? You don't have to be an expert in the field to notice who has a decent voice and who doesn't, distinguishing the good from the bad is a pretty basic talent in regards to music, everybody has the ability to do so. As long as you are not a teenybopper that is more interested in looks than talent you're fine in recognizing talent.