[Jamie89]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

There is actual evidence though Jamie.The only phsyical evidence points to Maddie dying in the apartment and cadaver scent was found not only in the apartment but also on Kates clothes

Wasn't the cadaver scent evidence deemed unreliable though? I think 'evidence' was probably the wrong word What I mean is there's no proof, or at least no evidence that's convinced me of their guilt.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Jamie89

Wasn't the cadaver scent evidence deemed unreliable though? I think 'evidence' was probably the wrong word What I mean is there's no proof, or at least no evidence that's convinced me of their guilt.

Well apparantly it would have been good enough to charge them in the UK but Portugese DNA evidence rules are tighter

[Jamie89]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

Well apparantly it would have been good enough to charge them in the UK but Portugese DNA evidence rules are tighter

Is that not because of the dogs used though rather than the evidence itself, I thought it was more because the Portuguese dogs had a much lower success rate in identifying the scent correctly (or the specific dogs that were used had a low success rate...I could be wrong about that but I'm sure it was the case?)